Review: Catching Fire

In the second installment of The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins, Katniss Everdeen must deal with the implications of surviving a gladiator-style fight to the death. Having defied the Capitol, she must prove that her actions in the arena were an act of love, not of defiance. The fate of her friends and family, and of Panem, rest on young Katniss’ shoulders. Catching Fire is a thriller at heart, action-packed and imaginative, though bursting with a bit more emotion than the first.

Well, let’s get down the business. If you’ve not read the book or series, I suggest reading it immediately. Oh, wait, you say you’re an adult and don’t like books for teenagers? Well, imagine Lord of the Flies on high-octane crack funneled through the perspective of George Orwell- now go read it. Once I finish the third and final book (why did it take me so long to pick these up?), I’ll post another review.

Major Spoilers Ahead. Go read the book, then come back to read my thoughts. All you need to know is, read it.

Katniss: She’s stubborn and brave and practical. The perfect heroine. Except she gripes a lot. “I’m hungry.” “My family is going hungry.” “They tortured my best friend.” Really, Katniss? The way she complains makes it seem like she lives in a totalitarian, brutal society.

The Love Triangle: This is where the book fails the most. Not that the book isn’t good, but it definitely does not have good romance. This is why the love triangle does not work: Peeta and Gale are the same person. They’re both fiercely in love with Katniss, slightly jealous of each other, willing to do anything for her, handsome, have great chemistry. Sure, one”s a baker’s son and the other works in a mine. One is rebellious and one is pretty much chill. I felt that in the first book, Collins didn’t give Gale enough face time to constitute any reader devotion toward him. Fortunately, in book two, the conflict was a bit more balanced. She kept flip-flopping. The problem is, she doesn’t even like Peeta. They’re friends who make out and marry and have a fake baby. While she is secretly in love with Gale, who acts basically exactly like Peeta with a few temper tantrums. Beyond that, it doesn’t matter who she ends up with. The best we can hope for is that one dies.

The Quarter Quell: If you’ve read the book, then you know that the characters return to the Hunger Games again, but this time one that feels very vapid. Almost lackluster. Not really that much fighting involved. Instead, dangers include rabid monkeys and force fields. The book focuses very little on the games, which I’m okay with. It might have seemed a little redundant. Although the games panned out differently because these included past victors, there was not much fighting. None of that bloody awesomness from the first book. No one starved or died too horrifically. And then of course it ended abruptly.

The characters: I like Finnick, who I feel is another of Collin’s hastily formed characters. That’s what Collins achieves at, taking minor characters and making them feel very real. Even Prim, who just sort of bumbles about and milks goats. I like Haymitch as well and believe that Katniss isn’t fully appreciative of how smart he is by the end of the Games.

Ethos: This book is quieter than the first. Finally, things began to set into motion. The huge problem is that Katniss rarely does much to fix her problems. Instead, things happen to her. Like the Quarter Quell. She begins to run away, but changes her mind. Because things must force Katniss into action, the book feels slower. Which was good, because you got to know characters beyond their skills in the arena. We learn more about Haymitch. Mrs. Everdeen emerges fully formed. Even the other contenders seem realer to me. Those moments of quiet meditation, those are nearly the best of all.

Overall: The plot was not what I expected, always a good thing. The end was actually… well, I expected all of that to happen. I admit, I thought she’d kill off either Finnick or Peeta. They both survived! Peeta, however, has an uncertain future as prisoner to the capitol. The cliffhanger did not bother me as it did other people because once I put down the second book, I picked up the third. Basically, the sequel lived up to the original suspense-wise and writing-wise. Despite Katniss being so ungrateful for being saved. I would probably be pretty stoked to not be dead. Stoked.

Collins has improved as a writer since her first series The Underlander Chronicles. I enjoyed those when I was about 13 years old, but I think that anyone of any age will appreciate The Hunger Games. This tale reaches far beyond conventional genre-limits.

About derekberry

Derek Berry is a novelist, poet, and student located in Charleston, SC.

Posted on June 30, 2011, in books, Reviews, Writing, YA. Bookmark the permalink. 2 Comments.

  1. You’re wrong about the love triangle, Derek. Gale and Peeta are two different people, and they are definitely more defined in the third book. Don’t make your judgements prematurely. You really are just a cynic, but I suppose I’m getting closer to seeing things are actually just that dark.

  2. I think the whole love thing is pretty ridiculous. I think I almost agree about the boys…Peeta doesn’t really have a personality. He just reacts to things and is in love with Katniss. Kind of reminds me of the twilight series in that way. Like, ooo everyone wants the girl we’re reading about, what does she do, what does she do?

    I thought the first book played it perfectly, her attitude towards Peeta the whole time, and almost forgetting about Gale, because really, her entire life is changed, she doesn’t get to go back, Gale is her old life, Peeta is her new one. Once she realizes she’s falling in love with Peeta, she should have just let it be. Why did she have to CONSTANTLY have to make herself pretend? She could have played the part perfectly without thinking, and actually enjoying her time with him, which is something she never realized…annoyed me a bit. Also the fact he didn’t realize she was pretending….umm…seemed pretty cheesy from where I sit.

    Overall though, like I said in my other comment, loved the series. First book was probably the best though, of them all, balance-wise.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: